The 10 Most Common Mistakes New Authors Make (And How to Avoid Them)
The moment a new author types “The End” on their manuscript is a monumental achievement. It’s the culmination of countless hours of creativity, discipline, and emotional investment. But for many, this milestone is quickly followed by the overwhelming reality of the publishing world. The path from a finished manuscript to a successful book is riddled with potential pitfalls, and the most common ones are often the most easily avoidable.
At bestsellingpublisher.com, we have guided countless authors through this journey. We have seen the same mistakes repeated again and again, whether an author is pursuing a traditional book deal or using the powerful suite of kindle publishing services to go it alone. The good news? These mistakes are not inevitable. They are stepping stones that, with the right knowledge, an author can sidestep entirely.
This comprehensive 3000-word guide will shine a light on the 10 most common mistakes new authors make and, more importantly, provide a clear, step-by-step roadmap for how to avoid them, setting the stage for a professional and successful author career.
Mistake #1: Skipping Professional Editing
This is, without a doubt, the single most critical mistake an author can make. The temptation to save money by self-editing or relying on a spouse or friend is a powerful one, but it is a false economy. A book with typos, grammatical errors, and clunky prose screams “amateur” and will quickly earn negative reviews and a reputation that is hard to shake.
Why It’s a Mistake:
A writer is too close to their own work to be an effective editor. They know what they meant to say, and their brain will often auto-correct errors, causing them to read what they intended, not what is actually on the page. A book’s quality is its primary sales tool. A poorly edited book, no matter how good the story, will fail to find a dedicated audience.
How to Avoid It:
Treat editing as a non-negotiable investment in your business. There are different types of editors for different stages of the process:
- Developmental Editors: For big-picture issues like plot and character arc.
- Line/Copy Editors: For sentence-level grammar, flow, and clarity.
- Proofreaders: For a final check for typos and formatting errors.By budgeting for and hiring a professional editor, an author signals to the reader that they are serious about their craft and have created a product worthy of their time and money.
Mistake #2: Judging a Book by Its Cover (And Then Designing a Bad One)
“Don’t judge a book by its cover” is a well-meaning sentiment, but in the marketplace, it’s a lie. Readers absolutely judge a book by its cover. A cover is a book’s primary marketing tool, and a bad one is a death sentence. New authors often try to design their own covers using free tools, resulting in a design that looks amateurish and out of place in their genre.
Why It’s a Mistake:
A cover’s job is to instantly communicate a book’s genre, tone, and promise. A self-designed cover, even if it looks aesthetically pleasing to the author, often fails to meet the visual expectations of the target reader. It blends into the background of the amazon book service marketplace instead of jumping out and saying, “I’m the book you’re looking for.”
How to Avoid It:
Hire a professional cover designer who specializes in your genre. A good designer knows the visual tropes of your genre and can create a cover that adheres to them while still being unique and eye-catching. This one-time investment in a professional cover will pay for itself many times over in increased sales and a greater perception of quality.
Mistake #3: Writing in a Vacuum
An author can spend years locked away with their manuscript, only to emerge with a book that doesn’t quite resonate with readers. Writing is a solitary act, but a successful book is a collaborative product. New authors often skip the crucial step of getting feedback from their target audience during the writing process.
Why It’s a Mistake:
Without feedback, an author cannot be sure that their plot works, their characters are compelling, or their pacing is effective. The first reader to encounter the book should not be a customer on Amazon, but a trusted beta reader or critique partner who can provide honest, constructive feedback.
How to Avoid It:
Find and cultivate relationships with beta readers. Beta readers are your target readers who will read your book for free and provide big-picture feedback on what’s working and what’s not. They can spot plot holes, confusing character motivations, and slow pacing long before the book is published. By incorporating this feedback, an author can ensure their book is ready for publication and has the best chance of resonating with a wider audience.
Mistake #4: Ignoring Metadata and Keywords
You can have the best book in the world, but if readers can’t find it, it won’t sell. In the digital marketplace of today, discoverability is everything, and it is driven by a book’s metadata. Metadata includes the title, subtitle, book description, categories, and keywords that an author enters on a platform like KDP. New authors often rush through this step, choosing generic keywords and categories, effectively burying their book in the online store.
Why It’s a Mistake:
Platforms that use amazon publishing services rely on a book’s metadata to determine who to show it to. Choosing generic keywords like “mystery” will put a book in a category with millions of competitors. A book’s success on the amazon book service marketplace depends heavily on an author’s ability to research and choose niche, long-tail keywords that their ideal reader is actually searching for.
How to Avoid It:
Treat metadata as a crucial part of your publishing strategy.
- Research Keywords: Use tools and an incognito browser to research what readers are searching for in your genre. Go for specific keywords like “cozy mystery with talking animals” instead of just “mystery.”
- Choose Niche Categories: Find specific sub-genres where your book can stand out and become a bestseller, which gives it a powerful discoverability boost.
Mistake #5: Setting the Price Wrong
Pricing a book is one of the most strategic decisions an author will make. A book that is priced too high may deter sales, while a book priced too low can give the impression that it is of low quality. New authors, in an effort to be competitive, often price their eBooks too low, missing out on the optimal royalty rate.
Why It’s a Mistake:
The most profitable royalty rate for a Kindle eBook is the 70% option, which is only available for books priced between $2.99 and $9.99. Pricing a book at $0.99 or $1.99 means an author will only receive a 35% royalty, effectively earning them less money per sale. For a new author, pricing a first book at $2.99 is a great way to earn a fair royalty while still being accessible to readers.
How to Avoid It:
Research the price points of books in your genre. Most authors using kindle publishing services find the $2.99 to $5.99 range to be the sweet spot for a new eBook. Price your book to be competitive, but also ensure you are earning the highest possible royalty rate for your work.
Mistake #6: Not Owning Your Rights (or Your ISBN)
Some publishing services offer to provide a free ISBN for your book. While this may seem convenient, it comes with a major catch: the service that provides the ISBN is listed as the publisher of record. This can be a huge mistake for an author who wants full control of their publishing business.
Why It’s a Mistake:
An ISBN is a unique identifier for a book. When a publishing service provides a free one, they become the publisher of record. This means they are the company that owns the distribution rights to that particular ISBN. This can make it difficult for an author to move their book to other distributors or make changes in the future.
How to Avoid It:
Purchase your own ISBNs from your country’s official ISBN agency. In the United States, this is Bowker. Owning your own ISBN allows an author to be listed as the publisher of record, giving them full control and flexibility over their book’s distribution and future.
Mistake #7: Relying Solely on KDP Select
KDP Select is a powerful tool for a new author, but it’s a double-edged sword. It requires an author to grant Amazon 90-day exclusivity for their eBook in exchange for powerful promotional tools and inclusion in Kindle Unlimited. New authors often put all their eggs in this one basket without considering the long-term strategic implications.
Why It’s a Mistake:
Relying solely on KDP Select means an author’s entire eBook business is tied to a single platform. A change in the algorithm or a new policy from Amazon could dramatically impact their sales and income. It also means an author is completely missing out on readers who buy their eBooks from other retailers like Apple Books, Barnes & Noble, and Kobo.
How to Avoid It:
Consider a hybrid publishing strategy. Many successful authors use KDP Select for the first 90 days to get a sales boost, then move their book to wide distribution after the exclusivity period is over. This gives them the best of both worlds: the initial boost from amazon publishing services and the long-term reach of wide distribution.
Mistake #8: Not Building an Author Platform
Many new authors think they should wait until their book is published to start marketing. This is a critical mistake. An author platform—an author’s pre-existing audience and their ability to reach them directly—is the foundation of a successful book launch.
Why It’s a Mistake:
A book launch without an audience is like shouting into an empty room. No one will hear you. A new author needs a dedicated group of people who are excited about their book and ready to buy it on day one. This audience is your best marketing engine.
How to Avoid It:
Start building your author platform today.
- Create an Email List: An author’s email list is their most valuable asset. It’s a direct line of communication to their most dedicated readers.
- Choose One Social Media Platform: Focus on one platform where your target reader is active and build an authentic presence.
- Create an Author Website: Your website is your professional home base online, the hub for all your marketing efforts.
Mistake #9: Treating a Book as a One-Off Product
The most successful authors are not one-hit wonders; they are career authors with a backlist. A new author often treats their first book as the end goal, not the beginning of a long journey. They pour all of their energy into one book, only to be disheartened when it doesn’t become an overnight bestseller.
Why It’s a Mistake:
The best marketing for a new book is an old book. A reader who loves your first book will almost always go back and buy your second. A large backlist is what creates a sustainable and compounding income stream.
How to Avoid It:
Write the next book. An author’s primary job after publishing is to begin working on the next one. By building a backlist and releasing books consistently, an author creates a business that grows with every new title they publish.
Mistake #10: Neglecting Reader Engagement
Publishing a book is a two-way street. A successful author-reader relationship is built on engagement. New authors often forget that their readers are a community and that engaging with them is a powerful way to build a loyal following.
Why It’s a Mistake:
A community of dedicated readers is the best marketing tool an author can have. They are your evangelists, your champions, and your most valuable source of word-of-mouth marketing. By ignoring them, an author misses out on an opportunity to build a powerful brand.
How to Avoid It:
Engage with your readers. Respond to comments and reviews, send out a regular newsletter, and use social media to connect with your community. By showing your readers that you value them, an author builds a loyal following that will follow them for their entire career.
Conclusion
The path to becoming a published author is no longer a mystery. With the tools provided by modern kindle publishing services, any author can bring their book to market. However, the path to successful authorship requires more than just a finished manuscript. By learning from the mistakes of those who have come before them, and by approaching their work with a professional, strategic mindset, an author can avoid these 10 common pitfalls and lay the foundation for a long and prosperous career.